Moving beyond 7th chords, we enter the huge, shimmering, full-orchestra sounding world of 9th chords. Simply put, 9th chords are extensions of 7th chords. In fact, there is a corresponding 9th chord for each of the three types of 7th chords:
Cma7 Dmi7 G7
Cma9 Dmi9 G9
Here is the structure for major 9th chords:
1 3 5 7 9
C E G B D = Cma9
2 1.5 2 1.5 = Major 9th structure
A brief intro to chord substitution is in order. Notice there are actually three triads contained in this Cmaj9 chord:
C E G = C
E G B = Emi
G B D = G
Also notice we can extend the Emi to Emi7:
E G B D = Emi7
It may seem early on to bring chord substitution into our discussion, but I feel it is important for you to begin viewing chords as more than one chord. In the case of this Cmaj9 chord, we really are looking at six different chords!
C = C E G
Cma7 = C E G B
Cma9 = C E G B D
Emi = E G B
Emi7 = E G B D
G = G B D
In practice, when I see a Cmaj9 chord on the music, I may play any of these six chords, depending on the effect I am after. In fact, I never view chords as one chord – and as you will see, I even throw out the concept of major / minor – but we have a ways to go before doing that.
For now, you can easily see for example if you played an Emi7 chord, with the bass player playing a C, we have a beautiful Cmaj9 sound – and in practice it is usually preferable, since doubling the bass can clutter the overall sound of the band.
Now let’s check out the structure for minor 9th chords:
1 3 5 7 9
D F A C E = Dmi9
1.5 2 1.5 2 = Minor 9th structure
Can you spot all six chords here?
Dmi = D F A
Dmi7 = D F A C
Dmi9 = D F A C E
F = F A C
Fma7 = F A C E
Ami = A C E
Here’s what happens when extending the dominant 7th to a 9th chord:
1 3 5 7 9
G B D F A = G9
2 1.5 1.5 2 = Dominant 9th structure
And here are the six chords within this G9 chord:
G = G B D
G7 = G B D F
G9 = G B D F A
Bmi-5 = B D F
Bmi7-5 = B D F A
Dmi = D F A
So, is the G9 a dominant chord? Glad you asked – the answer is yes, since it is simply an extension of the G7 chord, which contains the mi7 interval against a major chord. More importantly, inside all dominant chords is an interval that is not found in major or minor chords: the Tritone.
So, what the heck is a Tritone? As the name suggest, there are three (Tri) whole tones in the Tritone interval. Like P4, P5, and P8, the tritone is a perfect interval – there is no major or minor variant, and the tritone inverts to itself. The tritone interval in dominant chords is the distance from the 3rd to the 7th. Here it is within our G7 chord:
1 3 5 7 G B D F 1.5 1.5 = Tritone interval, 3 whole tones
This interval only occurs when two minor 3rds are joined together – since a minor 3rd is 1.5 steps, two of them equals 3 whole steps. Consequently, the tritone also occurs in our beloved mi-5 chord. Here it is in Bmi-5 and Bmi7-5:
1 3 5 7
B D F
B D F A
1.5 1.5 2
Since there are 12 half-tones to an octave, which equals 6 whole tones – the tritone interval with its 3 whole tones is exactly the center point of an octave! It produces a sound unlike any other, leaning toward the bluesy / jazzy side, but is found in nearly all forms of music. It is the dominant 7th sound, and is usually the strongest point within compositions – lots of tension that begs to be resolved.
We’ll be spending much more time on the tritone later on. The most important thing for now is to recognize it only occurs in the V and VII chords in every key, and is what distinguishes major 7th or major 9th chords from dominant 7th or 9th chords.
So, what is the difference between a G2 and a G9, since they both contain a A note? The answer is important, since this tends to be another one of those points of confusion, even for some accomplished musicians. Here is it:
The presence of the 7th determines whether a chord is called by its extended name or not. In fact, chord names beyond the 7th unto itself implies the presence of the 7th – i.e ma9, mi9 and 9th chords all imply a 7th is present in the chord.
Notice the difference between a G2 and a G9:
1 3 5 7 2 / 9
G B D A = G2
G B D F A = G9
G2 does not contain the 7th, in this case the F note. More importantly, since the 7th (F) is missing, there is no tritone interval in the G2 chord. Remember, in a dominant 7th chord, the distance between the 3rd and 7th is the tritone interval. G2 is a very major, resolved sounding chord – while G9 is a very dominant, unresolved sound – two completely different animals.
So now we are getting into the good stuff! These concepts may seem a bit much, but if you have been following all along, you should really have no problem here. Congratulations, we are smack in the middle of what I would term intermediate chord concepts, and it only gets better from here. In fact, we have just scraped the tip of the proverbial iceberg!
To help let all this “theory” sink in, we will be switching to guitar fingerboard concepts in our next blog, and get some practical application going. As always, please feel free to submit any questions or comments – we’ve covered some pretty intense stuff in a fairly short period of time – so any and all questions are encouraged. Until next time, I remain,
Musically yours,
Al
by Al Dinardi
02 May 2017 at 12:03
1 3 5 7 9
Emi9 = E G B D F#
Where you went wrong is an Emi9 chord has an F#, not an F. It is found in the key(s) of either D or G – both contain an F#.
by Al Dinardi
02 May 2017 at 11:57
1 3 5 7 9
Eb G Bb Db F
by Al Dinardi
02 May 2017 at 11:55
There are many ways to modulate keys. The most common is to navigate the chords to the dominant chord of the new key. In your example, going from the key of C to the key of G, the dominant chord (5 chord) in the new key of G is D7. You can play any type of D or D dominant equivalent chord. Further, it is common to precede the new dominant chord with the 2 chord of the new key. In the case of going to G, you could play Ami or Ami7 or Ami1, then D7 or D9, then the G tonic chord. Or, just play the Ami, Ami7, or Ami11 and go directly to G. Another option would be to precede the D with an F – the 4 chord of C. There are many other options – again, your ear and personal tastes are what matters most.
by Marianne Eubanks
31 Mar 2010 at 07:30
How simple!!! Thanks so much. Amazing how an easy answer can solve a mysterious problem. I think we’re both on team this weekend. If we run into each other and you have time, maybe we can go over that G#m9. It’s the beginning chord on ‘I Will Rise’ by Chris Tomlin. Eat your Wheaties. It’s going to be a busy, but wonderful weekend. Happy Easter, happy Resurrection Day!
by Al Dinardi
30 Mar 2010 at 09:45
Thanks for your kind comments Marianne.
The answer to both of your questions is in the Voicings. Chords played in root position voicings, that is from root and counting up through each 3rd inverval, are actually rare in practical application, particularly when it comes to chord extensions – 7th, 9th, 11th, 13th. Getting a pleasing sound that works well within the chord pattern of a song more often than not requires some re-voicing of chords.
A couple of good rules of thumb (no pun intended):
1) Isolate the most important notes – that is, the notes that make the chord the chord. For 7ths and above, you need the 3rd and 7th, otherwise there is nothing to give recognition to the chord’s Quality. These two notes are even more important than the root in my opinion – since the root only defines a chord’s pitch, not quality. The 5th is like the root, only defining pitch, unless it happens to be an altered 5th, then it becomes essential.
Faced with playing a 9th chord – the 3rd, 7th and 9th are essential. For a 13th chord the 3rd, 7th, and 13th are essential – the 9th is optional. There is no need to play every note leading up to a 9th, 11th or 13th chord – a much cleaner sound is produced by eliminating non-essential notes as much as possible – depending on the effect you are after.
So, in practice I usually play 13th chords with root, 3rd, 7th, and 13th – occasionally including the 9th depending on the effect I am after. This should also help with not running out of fingers on keyboard!
2) Once you establish the essential notes, begin shuffling the deck until you get a pleasing sound that fits the song.
Regarding your G#mi9 question – I need to see the music – as I see problems with your thinking on that one. Probably best to get together in person.
Otherwise, hang in there – it’s good to see you enjoying and benefiting from these posts.
by Marianne Eubanks
30 Mar 2010 at 08:24
I have a lot of catch up to do, but thank you, thank you for the section on 9ths. There are two comments that came up. A song I’m playing for Easter is in the key of G#m. The first chord is actually a G#m9 and I was looking at it the wrong way. The chord structure I had was
G#m B D# F# A#
No matter what interval I tried, it was ugly. I was creating the 9th off of G#m, instead of off the relative major of B, which would make the 9th C#. So now the structure I’m using is
G#m B D# F# C#
Much nicer tone. Thanks for clearing up my knowledge glitch in 9ths. But let me know if that is still not correct.
The second part relates to keyboard. Is that okay to ask a keyboard question. 9ths, 11ths, & 13ths puzzle me about how to play them. There are seven notes in a 13th, but only five fingers on one hand. Obviously, the root can be played with the left hand. I like to use a lot of different intervals and sometimes get creative about dropping notes. But what notes are correct to drop. The same goes with 9ths & 11ths. That leads to a ton of other questions, but I’ll stop with that one.
I so appreciate this forum. It’s getting me back to LEARNING again.
by Al Dinardi
19 Mar 2010 at 07:07
Though I always prefer creativity over rules of what to do or not do, here’s how I approach bass: generally, the strong beats (1 and 3 in 4/4 time) should include the root, while the weak beats are free to include any notes from the root scale. Depending on the music, it always sounds strong for the bass to follow the drummer, playing roots with the bass drum, with other scale tones following other drum instruments. The strongest scale tones for bass players to follow are those included in the chord – but any scale tone can be played to form strong, melodic bass lines.
That said, I approach chord substitution as any chord tone can become the root of another chord, as you saw in this blog. I’ll get into that concept in more depth later when I cover chord substitution. It is my contention, seeing multiple chords within chords encourages more freedom and creativity in music, giving musicians more command over their instruments and musical performance.
by Joe B
18 Mar 2010 at 20:39
ok Al, I get what you’re saying about how chords are put together. And I get how there are six different chords in ninth chords. So as a bass player, insted of playing the root note of the chord could I play the root of one of the other six chords. Or is it just best to stick with the root note and not mess anything up.